Does NLLS keep a list of books challenged at member libraries?
We encourage member library boards to review their policies related to information and procedures for handling challenges to library material. NLLS does not keep lists of challenges to materials made at its member libraries. However, we actively support intellectual freedom. For example, we participate in Freedom to Read Week. It is an important event for public libraries. Many libraries host special displays, programs and events. Information about Freedom to Read Week can be found at the Freedom to Read website.
Answer
Northern Lights typically does not directly experience collection challenges from the public. If an item is questioned regarding its placement in a library, NLLS will refer to our Collection Development Policy along with the endorsement of the Statement on Intellectual Freedom from CFLA (Canadian Federation of Library Associations).
Member libraries in NLLS are autonomous with their own governing boards. If a challenge were to occur at a specific library, the library staff and/or board would handle the challenge based on their own policies. NLLS is not always apprised of challenges that occur at member libraries, and the system does not maintain a record of challenges.
A Canadian agency called the Centre for Free Expression is a non-partisan platform focused on freedom of expression based in Toronto at the Toronto Metropolitan University. This agency provides a platform for public libraries called The Canadian Library Challenges Database to record challenges that have occurred at libraries across Canada, from collections, programs, displays, and usage of space. The forum enables the library to identify the specific challenge, how the library responded, and the decision made on the challenge. You can view this database here.
NLLS recommends that member libraries submit any type of challenge that they may have to this database so that the information can be shared with other libraries in Canada. To date, no libraries in NLLS have submitted information, but some libraries in Alberta have submitted content.
This KB article borrowed heavily from Laura Taylor of Marigold Library System.